Manchester United vs Lyon: Manchester United walked away from their Europa League quarter-final first leg against Lyon with a 2-2 draw—a result that felt more like a defeat. Despite impressive performances from young talents and dominant stretches of play, two critical errors from goalkeeper Andre Onana robbed the Red Devils of a potential victory.
This match was poised to be a statement of intent from Erik ten Hag’s side. Manchester United showed great attacking intent, creative midfield link-ups, and solid defensive structure for large parts of the game. However, the result ultimately highlighted a persistent weakness between the posts that continues to plague the club’s European ambitions.
Onana’s Blunders Undermine United’s Control
The opening goal for Lyon came in the 25th minute from what appeared to be a harmless free-kick by Thiago Almada. Onana, who had already been under scrutiny for his recent performances, completely misjudged the trajectory of the ball. The Cameroonian failed to assert his authority in the box, allowing the ball to bypass him and nestle into the back of the net. It was a mistake that not only gave Lyon the lead but also seemed to rattle United’s confidence momentarily.
Just when the Red Devils began to regain composure, Onana’s night took another nosedive in injury time. With United leading 2-1 and seemingly in control, a relatively straightforward shot was spilled by the goalkeeper. The rebound fell directly at the feet of Lyon star Rayan Cherki, who made no mistake in burying the equaliser in the 94th minute. The error undid all the hard work and momentum United had built during the match, drawing harsh criticism from fans and pundits alike.
Yoro and Zirkzee Shine Bright Despite Setbacks
While the result was disappointing, it wasn’t without its positives. Newly signed centre-back Leny Yoro proved why Manchester United spent £52 million on him. The young Frenchman not only scored the equaliser to make it 1-1 just before halftime but also delivered a standout defensive display. His confidence on the ball and maturity under pressure highlighted his potential to become a mainstay in the backline for years to come.
In the second half, United came out strong and began to dominate proceedings. Their persistence paid off when Bruno Fernandes, the team’s creative hub, delivered a perfectly weighted cross to Joshua Zirkzee, who powered home a header to give the Red Devils the lead. It was a goal that demonstrated Zirkzee’s growing influence and knack for rising to big occasions.
Midfield Battle Offers Mixed Results
Manchester United’s midfield had moments of brilliance, particularly through Manuel Ugarte and Casemiro. Ugarte sparked the first goal with a powerful volley that was redirected into the net by Yoro. Though his passing was inconsistent, his energy and ability to push forward added dynamism to United’s attack.
Casemiro, the experienced anchor in midfield, did well to control the tempo and came close to scoring with an acrobatic effort. His leadership on the pitch helped steady the side after Lyon’s opening goal and contributed to United’s resurgence in the second half.
Lack of Clinical Finishing Still a Concern
Despite controlling the majority of possession and creating numerous chances, United once again struggled to be clinical in front of goal. Rasmus Hojlund, in particular, looked short on confidence. He squandered a golden opportunity created by Patrick Dorgu, hitting a tame shot straight at the Lyon goalkeeper.
Alejandro Garnacho, while lively and aggressive in his runs, was guilty of poor decision-making in key moments. On multiple occasions, he chose the wrong option in the final third, stifling United’s momentum. These recurring issues continue to cost the Red Devils in tightly contested matches.
Ten Hag’s Tactical Approach Deserved More
Manager Erik ten Hag got many things right on the night. His tactical setup allowed United to dominate in midfield and create meaningful chances. The integration of young players like Yoro and Zirkzee is a promising sign for the club’s future.
However, his decision to stick with Onana as the starting goalkeeper—despite recent shaky performances—proved costly. Altay Bayindir, who has been waiting for his opportunity, could be in contention for the return leg if Ten Hag is ready to make a bold change in a crucial fixture.
Looking Ahead: Can United Recover in the Second Leg?
The return leg at Old Trafford will now be decisive. Manchester United must sharpen their finishing, remain defensively solid, and above all, resolve their goalkeeping dilemma. With the attacking firepower and young talent at their disposal, there is still hope of progressing to the Europa League semi-finals.
However, they can ill afford another night of self-inflicted wounds—especially from the one position where consistency is non-negotiable.
Final Thoughts
Manchester United’s 2-2 draw against Lyon was a classic example of promise being undermined by poor execution in crucial moments. Onana’s errors have become a recurring issue, and unless addressed, they threaten to derail the club’s aspirations in Europe.
With the spotlight firmly on the goalkeeper and the return leg approaching fast, Manchester United face a defining moment in their European campaign. The talent is there. The fight is there. Now, consistency and composure must follow.
